The thought experiment of maxwells demon and the origin of irreversibility. A little demon sits by a tiny trapdoor in the wall it looks at oncoming gas molecules, and depending on their speeds it opens or closes the trapdoor. There is a man doing multiple exercises, in between images of colorful waves. As individual gas molecules approach the door, the demon quickly opens and shuts the door so that only fast molecules are. We introduce and investigate a simple and explicitly mechanical model of maxwells demona device that interacts with a memory register a stream of bits, a. Video is embedded from external source so download is not available. Conditioning, correlation and entropy generation in maxwells. Prometheus is our first album, dating back to 2001. Maxwells demon, a hypothetical being that appears to violate the second law of thermodynamics, has been widely studied since it was first proposed in 1867 by james clerk maxwell. A thought experiment that seems to defy the 2nd law of thermodynamics. A new argument concerning conservation of phase space volume shows that all maxwells demons must fail.
Maxwells demon, hypothetical intelligent being or a functionally equivalent device capable of detecting and reacting to the motions of individual molecules. Researchers at an aalto university laboratory have been successful with a famous thought experiment, that has haunted the scientific community for more than 150 years. Since then this being, dubbed maxwells demon by lord kelvin, has been an active topic of. Even if the process of acquiring the information, and opening the door are reversible no entropy increase, the demon must store that inform. Maxwells demons realized in electronic circuits sciencedirect. Demon road available for download and read online in other formats. Less known is the time arrow of the phenomenon of evolution, which means design change 1,2. Maxwells demon conspires to use information about the state of a confined molecule in a szilard engine randomly frozen into a state subspace by his own actions to derive work from a singletemperature heat bath. Read the road to maxwell s demon conceptual foundations of statistical mechanics by orly r. Informationtowork conversion by maxwells demon in a. Its explanation for the ease of mixing milk with coffee is. Jeffrey bub, maxwells demon and the thermodynamics of. Its a 39 minute tone poem based on ayn rands novella anthem.
Demons, engines and the second law since 1871 physicists have been trying to resolve the conundrum of maxwells demon. Maxwells demon thermodynamics physics khan academy. A peculiar maxwells demon observed in a timedependent. These macromolecules gather information in order to recognize their substrate or ligand within a myriad of other molecules floating in the intracellular or extracellular plasm. During the 140 years since the demon was first suggested, numerous attempts have been made to counter maxwells argument. Fluctuations, maxwells demon and the thermodynamics of computation. The paradox of maxwells demon was proposed in a letter from james c. Studies in history and philosophy of modern physics 36 2. Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Yet the foundations of this theory are surprisingly shaky. Maxwell s demon md is a wizard of wisdom in a thought experiment.
It can separate the hot and cold gas molecule in a container box, thus creating a finite temperature difference between the two sides of the box and lowering the entropy of the system, which violates the second law of thermodynamics. Maxwells demon based on a threejunction array of small tunnel junctions. Norton, maxwells demon does not compute philpapers. Brownian computation is thermodynamically irreversible. While his body lays dormant in a rundown hospital bed, his mind is restless. Mar 29, 2018 maxwells demon is a hypothetical character that uses information about a system to reduce its entropy, highlighting the link between information and thermodynamic entropies. Do you think maxwells demon is possible and it can. Since the second law is taken by many to provide an arrow of time, the threat to its universality threatens the account of temporal directionality as well. Landauer s principle and the return of maxwell s demon.
May 16, 2017 maxwells demon is an imaginary entity that reduces the entropy of a system and generates free energy in the system. Enter your location to see which movie theaters are playing maxwells demon near you. Citeseerx accepted for publication in plos one september 6. Maxwell s demon is a thought experiment created by the physicist james clerk maxwell in 1867 in which he suggested how the second law of thermodynamics might hypothetically be violated. Also sign me up for fanmail to get updates on all things movies. Maxwells demon is an imaginary entity that reduces the entropy of a system and generates free energy in the system. We introduce and investigate a simple and explicitly mechanical model of maxwells demona device that interacts with a memory register a stream of bits, a thermal reservoir an ideal gas and a work reservoir a mass that can be lifted or lowered. Two similar and parallel agocs surfaces in a vacuum tube ceaselessly eject electrons at room temperature. The road to maxwells demon is an exceptionally clear and readable book, intended for readers without physics or philosophy backgrounds. Work and information processing in a solvable model of. The position of the partition in the demon s memory is the same as that in the case of the symmetric version.
Characterization of barriertunable radiofrequencysquid for. Color online the model of an asymmetric szilard engine. It is also a highly original and important contribution to the foundations of physics. How do we understand the number of words on the internet. A peculiar maxwells demon observed in a timedependent stadiumlike billiard. Maxwells demon posted on may, 2012 by deskarati in the philosophy of thermal and statistical physics, maxwells demon is a thought experiment created by the physicist james clerk maxwell to show that the second law of thermodynamics has only a statistical certainty. Two englishmen stand in the highlands of fiji, gazing up at a hill high above the village they are staying in. Viewpoint exorcising maxwells demon a pair of connected singleelectron devices functions as a maxwells demon that operates without external control.
Maxwells demon is a thought experiment devised by j. In 1871, james clerk maxwell proposed a thought experiment. If you create a free account and sign in, you will be able to customize what is displayed. If the fundamental physical laws do not require events to occur in any particular temporal direction, why do. Fascination with the demon persisted throughout the development of statistical and quantum physics, information theory, and computer science, and links have been established between maxwell s demon and each of these disciplines. Building on a model introduced by mandal and jarzynski proc. It was imagined by james clerk maxwell in 1871, to illustrate the possibility of violating the second law of thermodynamics. Maxwells demon is a film from the great experimental filmmaker hollis frampton, whose made some of the most hypnotic and great experimental films of all time, and this film impressed me quite a bit. Orly shenker time asymmetric phenomena are successfully predicted by statistical mechanics. We address the issue of the maximum work that can be extracted from the system in the presence of a feedback controller maxwells demon and provide a few illustrative examples. The separation of the ensemble of particles by their velocity, where a part of them exhibits fa and part shows retardation, is a clear evidence of a maxwells demon realization. Charges on the islands 1 and 2 of a biased voltage v array are monitored by the corresponding charge detectors, and feedback is based on the tunneling events observed.
A molecular demon or biological molecular machine is a biological macromolecule that resembles and seems to have the same properties as maxwells demon. Maxwells demon has been conceived as a tool for challenging the law of entropy increase. By dint of his prodigious intelligence and dexterity, the goblin could cause things to happen that are never seen to occur in nature, things that seemed able to violate the second law of thermodynamics. Among the very many puzzling aspects of the physical world is this. A static magnetic field applied to the tube plays the role of maxwell s demon. Fluctuations, maxwells demon and the thermodynamics of computation entropy 20, 15, 44324483 open access or download here. Prometheus is a music studio album recording by maxwells demon heavy progprogressive rock released in 2001 on cd, lp vinyl andor cassette. Entropy free fulltext conditioning, correlation and. Norton 2005 studies in history and philosophy of science part b. Maxwells demon, a concept by james clerk maxwell concerning the statistics of second law of thermodynamics evil demon, a philosophical concept originating with rene descartes darwinian demon, a hypothetical organism resulting from absence of biological constraints on evolution. Maxwells demon 2 entropy, classical and quantum information. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets.
Numerous and frequentlyupdated resource results are available from this search. One can therefore claim that the trapping in such a regime is due to stickiness which is still an open question and must be proved. First album from 2001 named prometheus find the band in musical influences somewhere between king crimson and anglagard or sinkadus, a well worth album but far from being something special. In the letter, maxwell mentioned his gedankenexperiment of a being whose faculties are so sharpened that he can follow every molecule. In the thought experiment, a demon controls a small door between two chambers of gas. The demon simply opened and closed an opening between two portions of a vessel filled with air so that. This is maxwell s daemon, an application that reads mysql binlogs and writes row updates as json to kafka, kinesis, or other streaming platforms. Here, the authors apply thermodynamics of information to signal. Note this is a simplified version of landauers exorci. Maxwells demon is a band from usa with two albums in their pockets so far. Oclcs webjunction has pulled together information and resources to assist library staff as they consider how to handle coronavirus. Maxwells demon, the famous thought experiment of james clerk maxwell, has been devised in 1867 as a counter example for the second law of thermodynamics. Efforts to exorcise maxwells demon have focused on the information processing a demon supposedly must do. Electrical maxwell demon and szilard engine utilizing.
Its hard to even grasp how many there are, and the number is growing so rapidly. If you want to convince me that you have built a maxwells demon, then give me a computer that i can plug into my bathtub. The being may be like a tiny fairy, and may violate the second law of thermodynamics. Power generator driven by maxwells demon nature communications. Reliable information about the coronavirus covid19 is available from the world health organization current situation, international travel. Jul 17, 2012 discussions of maxwells demon, landauers principle and related topics arise in contexts such as quantum information theory, the synthesis of artificial nanoscale machines, feedback control in microscopic systems 22. Here i draw attention to its earliest articulation in thermodynamics, which was maxwells demon for a. Maxwells demon tells the story of a man caught between dreams and reality. Maxwells demon 2 entropy, classical and quantum information, computing kindle edition by leff, harvey, rex, andrew f download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Several resolutions of the paradox have been proposed, making it clear that the demon does not violate the second law of thermodynamics. Maxwells demon is a hypothetical character that uses information about a system to reduce its entropy, highlighting the link between information and. Meir hemmo and orly shenker, the road to maxwells demon. Maxwell s demon is a band from usa with two albums in their pockets so far. The book is named for james clerk maxwells little imaginary genius, who could make your latte boil out of your travel mug given a chance.
The thermal electrons are so controlled by the magnetic field that they can travel only from one agocs surface to the other, resulting in collections of positive and negative charge on the two surfaces. Conceptual foundations of statistical mechanics kindle edition by meir hemmo, orly r. No, the demon must acquire information about the molecules motion to decide whether to let them through. Maxwell has low operational overhead, requiring nothing but mysql and a place to write to. Vain attempts to construct order word powers of ten february 2, 2012. We address the issue of the maximum work that can be extracted from the system in the presence of a feedback controller maxwell s demon and provide a few illustrative examples. An autonomous and reversible maxwells demon iopscience. Once you do that, we can all agree that we have a successful demon. From maxwells demon to landauers eraser eric lutz is a professor of theoretical physics at the university of erlangennuremberg in erlangen, germany. By changing the entropy of a tape consisting of a sequence of bits passing through the demon, the demon can lift a mass using the coupling to a heat bath.
Sergio ciliberto is a research director in the laboratory of physics at the ecole normale superieure in lyon, france. Ubuntu software center provides eclipse, but it is the 3. Some people will solve it with i think needlessly complicated information theory, but we can disprove maxwells demon with a truly elegant engine. Maxwells demon, but eddington reminds us that this work is not easy and that the price of failure can be high. Time asymmetric phenomena are successfully predicted by statistical mechanics. Over years ago, james clerk maxwell introduced his hypothetical demon as a challenge to the scope of the second law of thermodynamics. In letters from 1867 and 1871 and then in his 1871 theory of heat, james clerk maxwell described a tiny demon who could reverse the second law of thermodynamics. One of the earliest conceptual supercomputers was maxwells demon 2, who uses intelligence in sorting molecules to appear to evade the second law of thermodynamics. About 150 years after its proposal, theoretical studies explained the.
The beast, conjured in a thought experiment by james clerk. The attempts have been to show that maxwell was wrong, since his demon cannot work for one reason or another see. Maxwell in 1867 in order to show that the second law of thermodynamics is not universal, since it has a counterexample. Discussions of maxwells demon, landauers principle and related topics arise in contexts such as quantum information theory, the synthesis of artificial nanoscale machines, feedback control in microscopic systems 22. This edit will also create new pages on comic vine for. Maxwells demon, szilards eng ine and landauers erasuredissipation laszlo b.
657 350 430 163 1498 590 1274 919 776 662 1103 196 986 1557 184 908 155 626 1367 394 1511 1272 648 1489 919 300 559 853 830 1201 1034 489 1217 360 915 1231 1366